Rollators vs. Walkers: how to choose the right option for your needs
Many family caregivers assist loved ones with limited mobility. Daily tasks like using the toilet, getting in and out of the shower, and moving around the house present various risks, so support is crucial. However, these activities can also take a toll on your body, leading to physical exhaustion, muscle aches, and even burnout.
A mobility device, like a rollator or walker, can help prevent falls and free up time so you can focus on other responsibilities. But what’s the difference and how do you choose the right one to support your needs?
To answer these and other common questions, we connected with Calum Fraser, a physical therapist and owner of The Wellness Team, and Mercedes Fernandez, a geriatric physical therapist and CEO of Mouvement Geriatric Physiotherapy. Here, we feature their insights, answer some common questions, and highlight five of our best-selling mobility devices.
When Should Someone Consider Using a Walker or Rollator?
Encouraging someone to use a walker or rollator may seem invasive, but in certain situations, it’s the best and safest option.
While there’s no surefire way to know if you’ll benefit, Fraser suggests considering a mobility device if you can no longer walk safely, frequently stumble, or feel tired after moving. These devices can also be beneficial if you’re recovering from surgery or have a neurological condition, like Parkinson’s disease, that affects balance.
What’s The Difference Between a Walker and a Rollator?
Walkers and rollators are similar, but they aren’t the same. Here’s a quick breakdown:
Walkers
“Walkers are a four-legged mobility aid that must be lifted to move,” Fraser explains. “They don’t have wheels, so they require more effort to use, but provide better stability.”
Rollators
“Rollators are simply walkers with three to four wheels and a built-in seat,” Fraser says. “They’re made for people who easily experience fatigue and struggle with balance.”
Now that you know the difference between walkers and rollators, let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons of each.
Walkers: Pros & Cons
Fraser says walkers offer several benefits:
They’re lightweight, so the user doesn’t need to be strong.
They’re easy to use –– you don’t have to worry about maneuvering wheels or using brakes.
They enhance mobility for people with poor balance.
However, they also have some disadvantages:
Using a walker for long distances can be tiring and cause the user to become worn out.
Walkers require the user to exert effort with each step.
Outdoor surfaces like gravel, sand, and dirt can cause the walker to land unevenly, increasing the risk of falls.
Rollators: Pros & Cons
Fraser says rollators can be beneficial because:
The wheels glide smoothly, making it easier for the user to move comfortably.
The built-in seat allows for long-distance walks. Whenever the user gets tired they can sit down and take a break.
Rollators make it easier to move when turning.
Like walkers, there are also disadvantages to consider, including:
Rollators tend to be bulkier and heavier than walkers, so they aren’t as portable.
Because of their wheeled design, rollators require good balance and control. They may not be suitable for people who need a high-level of stability or have limited upper body strength.
Factors to Consider Before Buying a Mobility Device
Fernandez and Fraser say caregivers should consider several factors before buying a mobility device, including:
Your loved one’s physical capabilities (e.g. whether they can comfortably lift a walker or if they’d be better off pushing a rollator.)
Whether the device’s height can be adjusted.
Whether the device has soft, supportive grips.
How much weight the device can support.
If the walker or rollator can be easily folded up or broken down for transport. (This factor is particularly important for families who travel frequently).
Whether your loved one will be using the device indoors or outdoors. (For example, walkers are typically recommended for indoor use, while rollators can be used on different terrains).
If the walker or rollator has sturdy, non-slip feet or wheels (to reduce the risk of falls).
Whether the walker or rollator has accessories, such as a cup holder, backrest, or extra storage.
If the device supports your loved one’s medical needs. For example, someone with arthritis may need special grips to reduce joint pain and make movement easier. Alternatively, someone recovering from a stroke might need a built-in seat, so they can take breaks when they get tired.
When Is a Walker Better Than a Rollator?
Mobility devices aren’t one-size-fits-all, but a walker may be the right choice if your loved one:
Has significant balance issues. A walker’s sturdy, four-point base provides added stability.
Has hand problems. Conditions like arthritis can make it difficult to grip a rollator’s hand brakes.
Need mobility support indoors. Walkers can fit inside small rooms and inside narrow spaces, like hallways and doorways.
Is recovering from surgery or an injury. A walker can be a complement to physical therapy.
When Is a Rollator Better Than a Walker?
A rollator might be a better choice if your loved one:
Gets tired easily. Most rollators have a built-in seat so users can take breaks.
Is relatively mobile, but needs occasional balance support.
Enjoys spending time outdoors. Rollators have wheels that can safely move on various terrains.
Has good hand strength and coordination. Since rollators have hand brakes, they require more dexterity than walkers.
Take *THESE* Measurements Before You Go Shopping
Once you answer the questions above, you have a good foundation. But before you start shopping, we also recommend taking several measurements. Here’s what to measure:
The Height of the User
Have your loved one stand with their arms at their sides and measure the distance from the floor to their wrist. Then, write that number down. This gives you the ideal handle height for the walker or rollator.
Although most mobility devices have adjustable heights, measuring first helps guarantee the product you choose will be comfortable and functional, regardless of whether your loved one is tall or short.
The Width of the Device
Measure the width of any doorways, hallways, or other narrow spaces where the device will be used. Most walkers and rollators are 20-30 inches wide, but this can vary, measuring first helps guarantee a good fit.
Weight Capacity
While most mobility devices support up to 250 pounds, it’s a good idea to check the weight capacity, especially if your loved one needs extra support. Confirming their weight upfront can make shopping easier and help you make the right choice.
Seat Width (Rollators Only)
If you’re shopping for a rollator, measure your loved one’s hip width while seated. Then, compare that measurement to the product’s sizing information. A seat that’s any smaller than your loved one’s hips may make sitting uncomfortable.
Seat Height (Rollators Only)
Measure the distance from the floor to the back of your loved one’s knees while standing. The rollator’s seat should be just below this point, so it’s easy to sit down and stand up comfortably.
Carewell’s 5 Best Walkers and Rollators
After taking the necessary measurements, you’re ready to shop. Here are five of our highest-rated, best-selling mobility devices.
1. McKesson 4 Wheel Folding Rollator
This McKesson rollator has a durable steel frame that safely supports up to 300 pounds. It has a folding hinge for easy storage and ergonomic handles that support user comfort. The deluxe loop-lock system operates like a bike handbrake, helping the user slow down or stop as needed.
Key Benefits & Features
The handles are easy to grip, reduce hand pressure, and can be easily adjusted to accommodate the user’s height and preferences.
The rollator folds easily for hassle-free storage and transport.
The rollator has an oversized padded seat and backrest, so the user can stop and rest as needed.
Pros
This rollator supports users up to 300 pounds.
The wheels are 7.5 inches and suitable for indoor and outdoor use.
The rollator includes a fabric storage pouch, offering a secure place to hold your personal belongings.
Cons
Some users report that the rollator is wider than advertised and can be difficult to get through narrow doors and hallways.
Some users say this rollator is heavy and can be difficult to maneuver.
Hear It From a Caregiver: “The rollator is sturdy, well made, and light enough to put in my car's trunk or SUV.” - David R.
Price: $83.46 - $85.40
2. Drive Deluxe 3 Wheel Red Folding Rollator with Basket
This three-wheeled deluxe Drive rollator provides a safe and convenient way to get around. The handlebars and front swivel casters make it easy to steer, while the built-in lock button holds it secure when unfolded. This rollator comes with a wire basket and tote bag, so the user can store important items without having to dig through a purse or backpack.
Key Benefits & Features
This rollator supports up to 300 pounds.
The handle brakes and rear wheel locks make it easy for the user to slow down or stop.
This rollator can be folded up for easy storage and transportation.
Pros
This rollator includes several accessories, including a wire basket, a tote bag, and a tray for food and drinks.
The handlebars and front swivel casters make it easy to control and maneuver, even in tight spaces.
The lock button prevents the rollator from folding up during use.
Cons
Some users report that the basket is low quality and can’t hold much.
Some users say they wish this rollator came with a built-in seat.
Hear It From a User: “[I] love my three-wheeler. [It’s] easy to put in and out of the car, doesn’t take up much space, and serves its purpose.” - Iris H.
3. Medline Bariatric Heavy Duty Extra Wide Rollator
This Medline bariatric rollator is designed to support people with larger bodies. It weighs 18.9 pounds but can support users of up to 400 pounds. The wide set handles make movement comfortable for users who need extra room.
Key Benefits & Features
This rollator can support users between 5’4” and 6’4” tall.
The padded backrest and seat give users the ability to rest.
The handgrips are height adjustable for a perfect fit.
Pros
This rollator supports users of up to 400 pounds.
Made of heavy-duty aluminum that’s lightweight but strong.
Cons
The attached basket isn’t enclosed, so you may need to line it before storing anything inside.
This rollator may not be suitable for people taller than 6’4”.
Hear It From a Caregiver: “[This rollator was] easy to assemble. My wife likes it.” - Clifton M.
Price: $51.45 - $59.86
4. McKesson Aluminum Folding Walker with Wheels
This McKesson walker is made of lightweight aluminum but can support up to 350 pounds. The height is adjustable and the handles are covered in soft vinyl to ensure user comfort. The five-inch wheels on the two front legs glide along almost any surface, allowing the walker to move smoothly and easily.
Key Benefits & Features
The sturdy, one-inch aluminum frame is lightweight but provides strength and durability.
The U-shaped front cross-frame increases stability when the user is standing up and sitting down.
The push-button, dual-release mechanisms make it easy to fold the walker for easy storage and transportation.
Pros
Lightweight, affordable, and easy to use.
Supports up to 350 pounds.
The 17-inch grip width fits inside most doorways, hallways, and narrow spaces.
Cons
Some users report that this walker can be challenging to use on sidewalks, due to breaks in the concrete.
Hear It From a User: [This is a] very sturdy walker. After my total knee replacement, it was just what I needed.” - Ricki Z.
Price: $43.89 - $85.96
5. Drive Bariatric Aluminum Folding Walker, Two Button
This Drive bariatric folding walker can support up to 600 pounds. It has sturdy steel legs and side braces, and vinyl-contoured hand grips to support mobility wherever you need to go. Like the other mobility devices on this list, this walker can be easily folded up for storage or transport.
Key Benefits & Features
Designed to support people with larger bodies.
Each side operates independently, allowing for easier movements and greater stability.
The push-button mechanisms on the legs make it easy to adjust to the user’s height.
Pros
One of the only mobility devices capable of supporting up to 600 pounds.
The walker itself is lightweight and easy to maneuver.
The wheels on the front two legs glide over almost any service.
Cons
This walker is more expensive than other options.
Some users say that the wheels can get caught on floorboards and entryways.
Hear It From a User: “[This is] the walker I’ve been looking for. This one will fit through my bathroom doorway. Thank you.” - Deborah S.
Price: $104.99
Questions About Walkers or Rollators? Contact Our Friendly Care Team!
Selecting a mobility device, like a walker or rollator, can be daunting. Considering the impact it will have on your loved one’s life, choosing the right one is crucial. If you have questions or concerns, contact us any time. Our Care Team is available 24/7, including weekends and holidays. They speak English and Spanish and can help you make the right decision. Call (800) 696-CARE or email support@carewell.com.
Did you find this article helpful? Share it, print it or have it mailed to you!
Other Articles You May Like
The Best Supplies for Limited Mobility in 2024
Many older adults who require care also experience limited mobility. Devices like walkers, canes, and rollators can encourage independence at home, but more complex activities like bathing, changing, or using the toilet often require additional assistance.
Medically Reviewed by Kiera Powell, R.N.
A Beginner’s Guide to Exercising with Limited Mobility
Beyond the health benefits, exercise can enhance your quality of life and help you gain more independence. When you regularly work out, your muscles are stronger, your flexibility is enhanced, and you’re less likely to trip and fall.
Read More >Chad Birt is a freelance medical writer who resides in Astoria, Oregon. When he isn't behind a keyboard, you can find him hiking, camping, or birdwatching with his wife Ella and their two dogs, Diane and Thoreau.
Chad Birt is a freelance medical writer who resides in Astoria, Oregon. When he isn't behind a keyboard, you can find him hiking, camping, or birdwatching with his wife Ella and their two dogs, Diane and Thoreau.